PMDD vs. Regular PMS

September 26, 2025

PMS (or premenstrual syndrome) is sometimes treated as a joke: It’s the punchline in a lot of sitcoms, and it can be thrown about as a laughable issue in the company of all gender types. But though PMS can be a bit uncomfortable and difficult to deal with, it’s not technically a mental health issue.

Premenstrual dysphoric disorder (or PMDD), on the other hand, is a much more serious problem for which you might need treatment. But when issues around women’s mental health are sometimes laughed off, how can you know if you really need help? 

Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, takes the diagnosis of PMDD and its symptoms seriously. Tamara McDonald, DNP, wants patients to understand the difference between PMDD and regular PMS, as well as what to do about both problems and how to reach out when you need assistance. 

PMS and PMDD: the big differences 

Let’s start by defining PMS and PMDD. PMS is a group of symptoms that occur a week or two before your period starts. This condition is very normal, and almost everyone who menstruates will experience some form of PMS. It might cause emotions like sadness and irritability, and it can create physical symptoms like bloating and cravings. 

PMDD can cause all of these symptoms… and more. It’s usually considered to be a much more intense version of PMS, although this ignores the severity of the symptoms it can cause. PMDD creates bloating, stomach issues, cravings, irritability, and weepiness, but it can also cause severe mood swings and long-term issues like anxiety and depression. 

Around 5% of menstruating people are considered to have PMDD. While this seems low, it’s essential to remember that PMS, a much more common condition with milder symptoms, is often treated as something to be laughed off. As such, some people don’t seek help when they experience the severe symptoms of PMDD. 

How do you know it’s PMDD and not PMS

For one thing, PMS shouldn’t affect your daily life. You might snap at your partner or experience some constipation or diarrhea, but you shouldn’t be feeling suddenly hopeless, despairing, or miserable with your life because your period is coming on. Intensity is the name of the game with PMDD. 

In addition, if you’re noticing any symptoms that fuel thoughts of self-harm, you’re probably dealing with PMDD and not regular PMS. As previously stated, PMS can make you feel sad or melancholy, but it doesn’t make you feel depressed or suicidal. Thoughts like these are likely caused by PMDD, especially if they only occur before your period. 

Getting help for PMS and PMDD 

There are plenty of ways to deal with PMS at home, from taking a walk to resting and talking about your feelings with a close friend. All of these should help ease some of your uncomfortable symptoms until you start to feel better. And for the record, these can also help with PMDD, but you’ll need more to see real results. 

PMDD is a mental health diagnosis that requires treatment from a provider. First, talking about your feelings with a licensed therapist is incredibly helpful. Dr. McDonald can provide you with cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) sessions so you can learn to manage your symptoms more easily. Often, pharmaceuticals like antidepressants and birth control can also help.

Additionally, certain supplements can be beneficial in helping you manage PMDD, such as magnesium and vitamin B6. And finally, you may want to make some adjustments to your daily life. Cutting out excess sugar, caffeine, and alcohol can make it easier to manage PMDD, and having a regular exercise practice can also provide stability and relief. 

PMDD happens… and it can be treated 

Don’t let anyone make your mental health into a joke. You can get the treatment you need for PMDD and learn more about how the condition affects your mental and physical health. To learn more, simply visit us at our Boise, ID, office today. Call or book an appointment online. We look forward to meeting you. 

December 1, 2025
Mood disorders are common among women, yet they are frequently underrecognized or misunderstood.
December 1, 2025
For some individuals, the changes in mood, energy, and cognition that occur before menstruation can interfere significantly with daily life.
November 13, 2025
Do you tend to feel more stressed out, depressed, or otherwise like you’re struggling to get by during the holidays? It isn’t just you. Women deal with an increase in mental and emotional difficulties during the latter half of the year, and much of the time, this is directly associated with the holiday season. At Mind and Body Medicine, LLC , we will not only offer you help in learning about, and potentially addressing, any mental health conditions that may be present, but also in recognizing and managing generalized holiday stress. Tamara McDonald, DNP, is ready to provide you with the support you need so you can enjoy the holidays this year — perhaps like never before.
September 26, 2025
If you’ve dreamed your whole life of carrying a child, it’s devastating to be told that you may not or will not be able to experience it. Fertility grief is a real and painful part of reproductive mental health, and many people don’t realize how isolating it can feel until it happens to them. At Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, we want you to know you are not alone. Tamara McDonald, DNP, is always here to provide you with the kind of care that will allow you to navigate infertility grief and see the light on the other side, whatever that may look like.
September 26, 2025
Traditional therapy is an extremely helpful tool for mental health and well-being, whether you’ve been diagnosed with a specific disorder or not. In recent years, the number of those seeking therapy has increased, and many people experience myriad benefits from this type of care. But what if traditional therapy just doesn’t sound like enough? Or what if you feel like the process doesn’t allow for the kind of versatile and personalized care you need? If this is the case for you, it’s time to consider a modality called integrative psychiatry. Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, offers a number of mental wellness programs tailored to your specific needs. Tamara McDonald, DNP, uses her mental health training to offer a program for your unique situation. If regular therapy has always seemed like less than what you need, consider this option today.
September 26, 2025
Depression is a harmful, insidious mental disorder that can make it hard to experience joy, satisfaction, or any emotion at all. And unfortunately, it doesn’t just touch the people it affects directly. It can be very difficult to see a loved one struggle with depression, and sometimes, just knowing how to show someone you support them can feel impossibly far away. But there are ways to support someone as they cope with depression. And you can make a difference, even just by being there for your loved one. At Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, we offer mental health treatment for a number of disorders, including depression. Tamara McDonald, DNP, provides caring, holistic therapy that puts you at the center of your own wellness program whether you have depression, another mental disorder, or simply want to help support a loved one.
September 26, 2025
Though the understanding of mental wellness and the treatment of mental disorders has come a long way in our society, many people still balk at the idea of managing mental health with medication. However, medication management is just a part of the holistic treatment we provide at our Boise, ID office. Mind and Body Medicine, LLC offers more than medication to treat your mental condition; our pharmacological solutions are extremely individualized. Tamara McDonald, DNP, understands many people feel hesitancy around taking a pill for anything, but this treatment is often a vital part of wellness and mental health. Let us show you why.
September 26, 2025
It can feel devastating to realize that you might be suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD. But how do you really know? How is the condition diagnosed, and what can you do about it once you find out you have it? At Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, we know finding out what’s wrong can seem insurmountable. But it’s really only the beginning of the recovery process. Tamara McDonald, DNP, wants to help you diagnose the issue, start a treatment program, and begin the healing process, all of which may sound intimidating but can truly change your life for the better.
September 26, 2025
Having a baby is a milestone to which many people look forward. However, the experience can be quite different from what is expected, creating feelings of shame. But it’s important to own your emotions now so that you can safely and happily live your life as a mother and a person. Mind and Body Medicine, LLC offers many mental health treatment options, including those surrounding the reproductive system and process, as well as women’s mental health. Tamara McDonald, DNP, takes every case seriously and wants to remind current and future patients that feelings of sadness shouldn’t be overlooked, especially at this crucial time.
September 26, 2025
The question comes up a lot. Whether you’re a person with an anxiety disorder, questioning if the issue may be occurring in your life, or just wondering about a diagnosis for someone you love, you’ve probably asked yourself at least once, “Wait… I thought anxiety was just a normal thing everyone gets… right?” Actually, there is a kind of anxiety that’s typical, manageable, and well, normal, or not requiring therapeutic intervention. But there’s another type of anxiety that often requires help. Here at Mind and Body Medicine, LLC, we take all kinds of anxiety seriously, especially the kind associated with a disorder. Tamara McDonald, DNP, wants to help you understand the difference between common feelings of anxiety and a mental health issue, as well as how to manage both.